by TOBIAS SALINGER, Curbed NY, January 8, 2014

Proposed Chatsworth addition elevation North
Image: Montroy Andersen Demarco
Source: www.nyc.gov
Developer HFZ Capital picked up the iconic Chatsworth apartments at 340 West 72nd Street for a cool $150 million in 2012 and announced plans for a penthouse addition in October. Yesterday, representatives for the developer shared with the Landmarks Preservation Commission the plans by Montroy Anderson Demarco for two new floors atop the main building of the 1904 Beaux Arts structure and one extra floor on its annex building next door. But the team pushing for the rooftop additions, an external facelift for the façade, 24 new windows, and extra entrances could only sit and watch in silence as a dozen community members and preservation advocates bashed the design and representatives for three elected officials registered their bosses’ disapproval. The commissioners pointed out that it’s even more difficult to get approval for work on an individually landmarked building. “That really says to me that we need to scrutinize any changes more carefully,” said Commissioner Elizabeth Ryan of that designation.


